Repair or Replace: What to Do With Your Water Heater

In areas where the climate can fluctuate significantly, having a reliable water heater is essential for your comfort and daily needs. But when it breaks down, should you repair or replace it? This blog post aims to guide homeowners about the right time to have your heater repaired or replaced.

Your Water Heater’s Age

One of the first considerations should be the age of your water heater. Typical gas and electric water heaters have a lifespan of 6 to 12 years, whereas tankless models might last up to 20 years with proper maintenance. If your unit is relatively young and possibly still under warranty, repairing it often makes the most economic sense. However, for water heaters nearing the end of their expected lifespan, replacement might be a more cost-effective and reliable option.

Identifying Common Water Heater Issues

Water Not Heating Up

Before jumping to conclusions, check simpler issues like misadjusted thermostats or broken heating elements, which are often quick and inexpensive fixes. Adjusting the thermostat or replacing an element could restore your water heater’s functionality without the need for a full replacement.

Leaks and Water Accumulation

Finding water around your water heater doesn’t always signal a death sentence for the unit, but it’s a problem that needs immediate attention. Leaks could stem from loose fittings or more serious issues like a corroded tank. While tightening parts might resolve minor leaks, significant water leakage usually calls for a replacement, particularly if the leak originates from the tank itself.

Noise and Water Discoloration

Loud noises and water discoloration are red flags for water heater issues. Sediment build-up can cause both rumbling noises as impurities in the water bang against the sides and discolored water due to rust or sediment in the tank. Regular maintenance, such as annual flushing, can prevent these issues, but if they occur, it’s crucial to assess whether the unit can be efficiently repaired or needs replacing.

Evaluating Water Heater Capacity

Your household’s hot water needs can change over time; what was once sufficient might now fall short if your family has grown. If you find your current water heater struggling to keep up, upgrading to a larger capacity model or considering tankless options might be necessary for efficiency and comfort.

If you’re still having difficulty whether to repair or replace your water heater, you can always count on us at South Texas Piping to check your system and give you a birds-eye-view of its current condition. Call us at (832) 206-7589 or fill out this contact form to get started.